Abstract
In the United States, frontal lobe lesioning procedures have been uniformly linked to the neurologist Walter Freeman, although the prefrontal lobotomy was investigated in other institutions in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe, Russia, Japan, and China, mostly in patients with psychosis, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and/or intractable pain syndromes. These procedures were based on earlier reports of improvement of psychiatric symptoms after surgical resection of frontal lobe tumors and led many to infer a causal relationship between frontal lobe dysfunction and abnormal behavior. Freeman first visited Rochester, MN, as a medical student in a gastrointestinal laboratory at the Mayo Clinic. Freeman visited Rochester again many years later, a visit that was received with trepidation but ultimately led to the adoption of his lobotomy method. Freeman's grandfather, W.W. Keen, was a highly respected surgeon credited with the first successful surgical resection of a benign brain tumor in the United States, a connection that may have contributed to Freeman's subsequent interest in performing lobotomies. Keen maintained a close relationship with the Mayo brothers and also advocated for Freeman's initial visit to the Mayo Clinic. In this article, we present a brief historical review of Freeman and the early reports of the prefrontal lobotomy procedure performed by consultants affiliated with the Mayo Clinic and Rochester State Hospital.
Overview
- The study focuses on the history of frontal lobe lesioning procedures, specifically the prefrontal lobotomy, and their association with Walter Freeman. The methodology involves a review of historical records and literature related to the procedure and its development in the United States, United Kingdom, Europe, Russia, Japan, and China. The primary objective is to provide a historical context for the prefrontal lobotomy and its evolution over time.
Comparative Analysis & Findings
- The study finds that the prefrontal lobotomy was investigated in various institutions in the United States, United Kingdom, Europe, Russia, Japan, and China, with the majority of these studies focusing on patients with psychosis, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and/or intractable pain syndromes. The procedure was based on earlier reports of improvement of psychiatric symptoms after surgical resection of frontal lobe tumors, leading many to infer a causal relationship between frontal lobe dysfunction and abnormal behavior. The study also highlights the connection between Freeman's grandfather, W.W. Keen, and the Mayo Clinic, which may have contributed to Freeman's subsequent interest in performing lobotomies.
Implications and Future Directions
- The study's findings provide a historical context for the prefrontal lobotomy and its evolution over time. The study highlights the importance of considering the historical context when evaluating the effectiveness and safety of medical procedures. The study also suggests that future research should explore the role of family history and personal connections in shaping medical decisions and practices.